a16z
April 28, 2025

The Software Crisis Behind America's Infrastructure

This discussion dives into the critical software challenges underpinning America's vital infrastructure, from aviation to defense logistics. Featuring Philip von Purpose, co-founder of ASI, and Leo Kosinski, a recently retired 3-star Air Force general formerly directing logistics for the Joint Chiefs, it explores why modernization is failing and how a new approach is essential for national security and economic stability.

The Crumbling Foundation: Legacy Tech in Critical Sectors

  • "What we saw was like the most ancient software possible..."
  • "We got legacy software that is faltering, that is falling apart..."
  • Aviation and defense logistics run on "ancient," brittle software systems prone to failures with massive consequences (e.g., FAA outages).
  • The core issues—staffing shortages, outdated infrastructure, and the software crisis—are interconnected. Better software can improve training, productivity, and retention, addressing staffing woes.
  • New generations entering fields like air traffic control find legacy "green screen" systems alien compared to modern interfaces, hindering training and adoption.

A Broken Philosophy: Building Software Like It's Hardware

  • "Historically software in this domain has been built as if it would be hardware..."
  • "The first thing that happens is like a thousand-page documentation is written... tens of millions of dollars are spent on just writing the documentation. No software built yet."
  • Government and critical infrastructure software modernization often follows a hardware-centric model: massive upfront requirements docs, years of custom development, resulting in outdated tech upon deployment.
  • This slow, rigid process fails to attract top software talent, who prefer rapid iteration and user proximity.
  • Legacy systems often tightly couple software and compute, requiring physical updates facility by facility, hindering agility. The crucial first step is separating software from specific compute hardware.

Contested Logistics: The Invisible Weakness

  • "Logistics... it's your competitive advantage if you can leverage it. If you can't and you don't see it, it becomes your greatest weakness and vulnerability."
  • "You can build the most advanced equipment... but if you can't get it where it's needed, when it's needed, it doesn't exist."
  • Logistics, often an afterthought, is now a "contested" domain, actively targeted by adversaries and vulnerable to disruption (weather, cyber, physical attacks). Examples include the Colonial Pipeline hack and Suez Canal blockage.
  • Effective logistics is fundamental to military power projection and deterrence; failing supply chains render advanced weapons useless.
  • The US reliance on "just-in-time" models creates fragility. Resilience requires predictive capabilities and understanding logistics as a strategic asset, not just a cost center. Adversaries exploit these vulnerabilities.

The Path Forward: Dual-Use Tech and Predictive Power

  • "Anticipation in many ways is the new high ground."
  • "When it comes to some of these industries where the private sector and the public sector have to collaborate very closely together, dual use is a phenomenally good idea."
  • Modernization must shift from slow custom builds to adopting proven, commercially available "dual-use" software. This is faster, cheaper, and safer, leveraging existing, deployed technology.
  • Dual-use platforms (like ASI's) enable vital collaboration between commercial operators (airlines, shipping) and the government/military, sharing data and capacity seamlessly, especially crucial in crises.
  • The future lies in "prediction machines"—AI-powered software that anticipates disruptions, optimizes resource allocation, hardens networks against threats, and provides decision support, overcoming training bottlenecks.

Key Takeaways:

  • Modernizing America's critical infrastructure software isn't just about efficiency; it's a national security imperative in an increasingly uncertain world. The old ways of building and deploying software are too slow and fragile for the challenges ahead.
  • Embrace Dual-Use: Stop reinventing the wheel; leverage proven commercial software for faster, cheaper, and more effective modernization in sectors like logistics and aviation.
  • Logistics is Strategy: Treat logistics not as a cost center but as a critical competitive advantage and potential vulnerability that requires proactive investment and predictive capabilities.
  • Urgency is Paramount: The slow, bureaucratic approach to software modernization is failing. Adopt agile methods and prioritize deploying predictive, resilient systems now before crises hit.

Podcast Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=boG78ZxL0OE

Here are the detailed, narrative-driven show notes tailored for Crypto AI investors and researchers:

Episode Show Notes: ASI - Modernizing Critical Infrastructure

This episode dissects the software crisis undermining US aviation and defense logistics, exploring how legacy systems create vulnerabilities and why AI-driven modernization is critical for future security and operational dominance.

Philip's Journey: From German Stagnation to Silicon Valley Drive

  • Philip describes his frustration with Germany's early 2010s environment, characterized by economic stagnation, a pull-back from nuclear energy dependency on Russian gas, and limited entrepreneurial ambition among peers. He contrasts this with the allure of Silicon Valley.
  • Seeking a fast-paced, building-focused environment, Philip moved to Palo Alto around 2012, immersing himself in the hacker house culture. He emphasizes the unique American ecosystem and ethos that enabled his journey. "It sounds like everyone is just obsessed with building and technology," Philip recalls of his initial impression of Silicon Valley.
  • This experience highlights the power of dynamic tech ecosystems in fostering innovation, a relevant insight for those building or investing in cutting-edge fields like Crypto and AI.

Identifying the Software Gap: From Autonomous Cars to Critical Operations

  • Philip and co-founder KD Lucas, initially outsiders to aviation and defense with backgrounds in autonomous driving (around 2017-2018), felt the autonomous vehicle space was becoming overcrowded.
  • They founded ASI by exploring other transportation sectors needing better software. Investigating maritime and air operation centers, they expected advanced tech but found the opposite.
  • "What we saw was like the most ancient software possible," Philip states, revealing the significant gap and opportunity that led to ASI's mission: optimizing critical national assets and infrastructure through modern software. This discovery mirrors opportunities often sought by tech investors in underserved legacy markets.

Leo's Perspective: Decades of Military Logistics Experience

  • Leo, a recently retired three-star general, brings over 30 years of military experience, primarily in air mobility and logistics, including serving as Director of Logistics for the Joint Chiefs.
  • His decision to join ASI stemmed from recognizing the critical need for data access and optimization in defense logistics—a challenge he directly experienced. He notes the potential of startups like ASI to impact both military and strategically important commercial sectors.
  • Leo mentions his early graduate work in industrial engineering and neural networks, predating sufficient processing power, connecting his long-standing interest in optimization to today's AI capabilities. His perspective underscores the real-world operational bottlenecks created by data silos and outdated systems, problems AI/ML is well-suited to address.

The Aviation Software Crisis: Beyond Staffing Shortages

  • Philip outlines three interconnected problems in aviation: significant staffing shortages (due to COVID-era retirements/training lags and difficulty attracting top talent), faltering legacy software causing major outages, and outdated infrastructure.
  • Crucially, he argues these aren't isolated issues. Better, intuitive software could accelerate training, boost operator productivity (fewer clicks, AI assistance), potentially increase pay, and attract more talent.
  • "Staffing and infrastructure are fundamentally actually software problems," Philip asserts. Modernizing software is essential not just for efficiency but also for training the next generation of operators accustomed to modern interfaces, not IBM green screens.

The Broken Philosophy: Why Critical Software Stagnates

  • Philip identifies a core "philosophy problem" hindering modernization in critical sectors:
    • Software/Compute Coupling: Legacy systems tightly link software to specific hardware, making updates across geographically dispersed facilities incredibly difficult and risky. Separating software from compute is essential for future adaptability.
    • Building Software Like Hardware: Traditional processes involve massive upfront documentation, years of development against fixed requirements, resulting in outdated systems upon deployment. This contrasts sharply with modern, iterative software development. "Software is never complete. Software is moving incredibly fast," Philip emphasizes.
    • Talent Drain: The best software engineers are often unattracted to these slow, rigid development environments, preferring rapid iteration close to the user.
  • This critique resonates with agile principles common in tech and crypto, highlighting the need for modern software practices in vital national infrastructure.

The Path to Modernization: Urgency, Funding, and Smarter Spending

  • There's growing urgency and bipartisan support for modernizing systems like those at the FAA (Federal Aviation Administration), driven by recent events and administration focus.
  • Philip stresses the need for adequate funding but cautions against repeating past mistakes. Instead of decade-long custom builds, he advocates for purchasing proven, commercially available software already deployed successfully (e.g., by airlines).
  • This approach offers faster, safer, and more efficient modernization by leveraging existing, validated solutions—a strategy relevant to platform adoption decisions in the Crypto AI space.

ASI's Dual-Use Strategy: Bridging Commercial and Defense Needs

  • ASI exemplifies a "Dual-Use" approach, where technology serves both commercial and government/defense markets. Their software, proven in the commercial airline sector, was rapidly deployable for the US Air Force in live operations.
  • Philip argues logistics is a prime candidate for dual-use. The military relies heavily on commercial capacity (trucking, rail, air, sea), and critical commercial infrastructure benefits from military-grade software resilience.
  • "Dual use is a phenomenally good idea. Not just because it's more efficient, but it also enables more collaboration," Philip states. Using similar software stacks facilitates vital communication and data sharing between sectors, especially crucial during crises. This highlights a significant market opportunity and the value of interoperable platforms.

Understanding Contested Logistics: Beyond Smooth Deliveries

  • Leo defines "Contested Logistics," a military term referring to logistics operations facing challenges—from weather and maintenance issues to deliberate adversary actions targeting supply chains. This contrasts with the assumed reliability of consumer deliveries.
  • He stresses that adversaries actively seek vulnerabilities in supply chains. Furthermore, deploying forces requires immense logistical support (food, munitions, sustainment). Without reliable logistics, even advanced weapon systems are ineffective.
  • "Logistics and experts do think of it as a weapon system itself," Leo asserts. It can be a critical competitive advantage if managed well, or the greatest vulnerability if neglected. This frames logistics as a complex system optimization problem under potential duress, ideal for AI-driven solutions.

Why Logistics Was Overlooked: Complacency and Cost Focus

  • Leo suggests that after decades without large-scale conflict, there's a human tendency to revert to a comfortable status quo, overlooking underlying vulnerabilities exposed during crises like the pandemic.
  • Historically, logistics was often treated purely as a cost center, optimized for "just-in-time" efficiency, which fails when supply chains are disrupted.
  • The necessary shift, now being recognized by companies and defense planners, is to view resilient logistics and supply chains as a strategic, competitive advantage, requiring proactive investment rather than being an afterthought.

The Power of Collective and Integrated Logistics

  • Philip reinforces the dual-use argument by highlighting shared infrastructure (like ports) and adversary actions (e.g., China deploying software in allied ports). This necessitates secure, potentially shared software systems for collaboration.
  • Leo introduces the concept of "Collective Logistics" emerging within NATO. Historically, logistics was a national responsibility, but the realization is "any one nation can't do it alone." This involves planning and utilizing allies' collective logistics capabilities.
  • This move towards integration and shared platforms underscores the importance of interoperability and common standards, key principles relevant to building robust, collaborative Crypto AI ecosystems.

Modernizing DoD Logistics: From Dashboards to Predictive Power

  • Philip critiques past modernization efforts that often resulted in just "new dashboards" showing near real-time data. In today's more dynamic ("spicier") world, reactive monitoring isn't enough.
  • He outlines software's evolution: from standalone Compute (1970s/80s) -> Connectivity (Internet) -> Data Fusion (IoT, common operating pictures) -> the current frontier: Prediction Machines.
  • These systems aim to predict the future state of operations (hours, days, weeks ahead), allowing operators to anticipate problems and adjust proactively. "Anticipation in many ways is a new high ground," Philip argues. Leo adds that AI decision tools can also accelerate the training of skilled logisticians. This is the core AI application discussed: moving from reactive displays to proactive, AI-driven foresight.

The 10-Year Vision: AI-Enabled Resilience and Deterrence

  • Looking ahead 10 years, successful AI-driven logistics modernization should enable:
    • Doing significantly more with existing capacity.
    • Hardening logistics networks against disruptions (geopolitical, climate-related, etc.) through predictive rerouting and balancing.
  • Leo emphasizes the link to deterrence: robust, resilient logistics demonstrates the ability to sustain operations, which adversaries notice. "If you can't sustain them... that doesn't provide that deterrence," he states. AI is key to achieving this dynamic resilience.

The Stakes: Risks of Stagnation and Inaction

  • Leo stresses the urgency, referencing Michael Pillsbury's "The Hundred-Year Marathon" concept—adversaries like China have studied US supply chain vulnerabilities for decades.
  • He points to real-world examples (Colonial Pipeline cyberattack, Suez Canal blockage) and emerging threats (hypersonic missiles, cyber intrusions into critical infrastructure like water systems) that make uncontested logistics a thing of the past. Adversaries may aim to win without fighting by crippling logistics.
  • Philip adds the need to understand the threat profile for every node (ports, cables, etc.) in the system. The risk of inaction is a fragile system vulnerable to cascading failures, undermining national security and economic stability. "The best type of war you fight is one that you don't have to fight at all," Leo quotes, underscoring the deterrent value of resilient logistics.

Conclusion

The discussion highlights critical infrastructure's dangerous software vulnerabilities. AI-driven predictive logistics and dual-use platforms are vital for resilience and deterrence. Crypto AI investors/researchers should monitor companies pioneering these solutions and the strategic shift towards proactive, data-centric security postures in national infrastructure.

Others You May Like